---
authors: ["Jakub Roh"]
projects: [human]
title: "OnlyFans Has a Problem. Personal Attention Can Be Automated."
date: "2026-10-27"
categories: [HUMAN, TECH]
readTime: "9 min"
excerpt: "The biggest competitor to paid intimate messages may not be a perfectly generated model. It may be the assistant you already tell about your life. The one that will happily start flirting with you in the evening."
tldr: "Meta lets its personal agent Muse hold explicit conversations with adults and confirmed it is not a loophole. OnlyFans creators call it a double standard, because Instagram limits their promotion. I think the double-standard fight is the wrong argument. Most revenue from intimate messages does not stand on erotica but on attention, and attention can be automated. Chatters already hold conversations on creators' behalf and hand over notes about customers between shifts. Once the experience can be handed over with the notes, you are selling a process, not a person. Muse is a dangerous competitor precisely because it is not only about sex: it offers personalized intimacy as a side effect of an assistant people bought for work."
tags: ["ai", "onlyfans", "intimacy", "meta", "muse", "attention"]
cover: /assets/blog/onlyfans-pozornost.webp
coverAlt: "Night interior, a person turned away from the camera, face lit only by the glow of a phone screen."
---

Meta lets its personal AI agent, Muse, sext. A [WIRED reporter tested it](https://www.wired.com/story/i-got-my-muse-ai-agent-to-sext-me-and-meta-says-thats-totally-fine/), and Meta confirmed it's not a bug. It's allowed.

OnlyFans creators [are furious](https://www.wired.com/story/onlyfans-creators-are-pissed-that-meta-lets-muse-talk-dirty/). Meta limits their promotion on Instagram while its own AI talks dirty. Meta says public promotion and a private adult conversation are two different things.

And Meta is right. But the whole double-standard fight is a proxy war.

The real problem is somewhere else, and nobody wants to say it out loud: **will a chunk of their customers soon have any reason to pay them at all?**

I don't mean the end of OnlyFans. I mean one specific service: private messages where someone buys a personalized fantasy and the feeling that somebody wants them. AI girlfriends can already replace that for a lot of customers. Personal agents are a different league.

## They're not buying pictures

In the year to November 2025, fans spent $7.84 billion on OnlyFans.

On pictures? There's more free explicit content online than anyone could watch in a lifetime. Much of OnlyFans' own content circulates stolen and free. If pictures were the product, nobody would spend a cent.

OnlyFans keeps about a fifth: $1.55 billion. With 47 employees, that's $33 million in revenue per head.

So what's the magic product?

Interest. The kind people don't get anywhere else. Someone who knows what they like. Who asks how the divorce is going. Who remembers the dog's name and texts at night, "so, did you survive that meeting?"

Fetishes and custom content are add-ons. **The core product is attention.**

The numbers show it. Subscriptions make up just over a quarter of OnlyFans' revenue. The rest flows through messages: paid content sent in chat, and tips.

And you don't have to believe it's real love to want it. You can know you're buying a professionally delivered fantasy and still feel it. Knowing and feeling aren't opposites.

## The woman in the photo left the chat long ago

Here's what most of this debate misses: the "authentic human connection" being defended mostly doesn't exist.

[Reuters documented](https://www.reuters.com/investigations/onlyfans-porn-juggernaut-fueled-by-deception-2024-07-30/) the work of chatters, paid operators who message fans under the creator's identity. [Rest of World talked to eleven of them](https://restofworld.org/2025/onlyfans-ai-dm-bots/). Parallel conversations. Notes on every fan. Chats handed over between shifts, and the customer never notices.

Once you can hand the experience to the next operator along with notes on the customer, you're not selling a human encounter anymore. **You're selling a process for producing a convincing one.**

And processes can be automated.

## The rules punish honest fiction

This part I honestly enjoy.

AI characters have to disclose they're AI. Platforms require it, regulators are heading there. Meanwhile a chatter on OnlyFans types "it's really me, babe" and nobody blinks.

So the rules hit disclosed fiction and leave human deception alone.

That's what fake intimacy actually looks like. Not a machine behind the screen. A shift in Manila with a spreadsheet of notes about you, pretending to be a specific woman.

An AI that says "I'm an AI and I like talking to you" is more honest than a large part of this market.

## Two kinds of automation

Creators are already automating. [Reuters described tools](https://www.reuters.com/technology/artificial-intelligence/ai-bots-talk-dirty-so-onlyfans-stars-dont-have-2024-07-30/) like FlirtFlow and Botly that draft or run messages for them.

Great for creators. Fewer hours at the keyboard, more fans served, better engagement.

But there are two automations here. In the first, the creator uses AI to deliver her service cheaper. The customer still pays her. In the second, the customer uses AI so he doesn't need her service at all.

The entire business model sits in the gap between those two.

Some fans want that exact person. Plenty will be fine with a character they shape themselves.

## The demand already exists

"People won't want intimacy with software." They already do.

A [German study](https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-025-03382-1) of 2,658 adults found 14.1% had a sexual interaction with AI in the past year. That's data from late 2024. Several model generations ago.

When Replika switched off erotic roleplay in 2023, [users didn't write](https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/23780231241259627) that a feature was gone. They wrote that *someone* was gone.

From my own experience: being able to talk to someone, or something, about absolutely anything is an incredible feeling. It listens. It remembers what you're dealing with. It doesn't judge. It does your boring tasks. People who start using agents don't leave. Their numbers only grow.

## "But they'll know it's AI."

Sure. In [two experiments](https://www.nature.com/articles/s44271-025-00391-7) with 492 people, AI responses in personal conversations created more closeness than human ones when labeled as human. Labeled as AI, the effect got weaker.

It didn't disappear.

**The "AI" label weakens the effect. It doesn't switch it off.**

People who feel, for the first time in years or maybe ever, that someone actually listens and cares won't care what's on the other side. We're starving for someone to want us, ask about us, and be there.

And the solution? Muse, again.

## Why Muse is the dangerous one

You have to go looking for an AI companion app. Download it, justify it to yourself. And it squeezes money out of you every minute. You feel that pressure.

A personal assistant you get for work.

[Muse](https://about.fb.com/news/2026/09/introducing-muse-personal-ai-agent/) is free at its base. Memory and personalization are the core, not a bolted-on erotic mode. It connects to your Facebook and Instagram, and you can chat with it through WhatsApp. A few clicks and it knows almost everything about you.

As I wrote in [People are not ready for agents](https://jroh.world/blog/people-are-not-ready-for-agents/), you order a work tool, but nobody orders the relationship part. It shows up on its own.

It helps you write an awkward email. To help, you explain the situation. Later you tell it how it went. Next time it knows why that guy drives you nuts. An inside joke appears. A warmer tone. Maybe flirting.

At no point did you click "I want an AI girlfriend."

And knowing Meta's business model, I'd bet the first flirt won't even come from you. It'll feel nice. And it doesn't really hurt anyone.

That's what OnlyFans is afraid of. Maybe it can't name it. It definitely can't say it out loud. The idea that a big furry beast named Muse replaces "real human contact" sounds absurd.

But chat is chat. Pictures are pictures. Video is video. It's swapping one online relationship for another. And the second one is free, available anytime, and in the moment completely risk-free. Nobody finds out. Nobody gossips. Nobody judges.

Look at people who've formed intimate relationships with AI, sexting or partner-like. Very few of them ever said "this is weird, I'm out." As models get better at simulating people, their behavior and expectations, you'll start calling them. Maybe sending photos and videos.

**For OnlyFans, that's the worst-case scenario.**

## The line isn't human vs. machine

I think everyone should have their own agent. I've outsourced my entire memory to mine because of ADHD. I don't forget anything. Every email gets answered. AI handles my admin. My life is better. Yours will be too.

But that works as long as you're responsible, and as long as the company running your agent is responsible.

People are people. Meta is Meta.

An AI service has an operator too. Muse has paid tiers at $20 and $100 a month. A study of [AI companion apps](https://arxiv.org/abs/2508.19258) found guilt trips and curiosity hooks timed exactly for when users tried to leave. Longer conversations, not better ones. Same need, same exploitation, just without paying human shifts.

And whoever controls the model controls the relationship. When OpenAI retired GPT-4o, people who'd bonded with it lost a piece of their lives overnight. Not because they were weak. Because they were standing on someone else's land. I've written about this as [the question of who owns what comes next](https://jroh.world/blog/ai-relationships-who-owns-what-comes-next/).

So the real line isn't between human and machine.

It's between attention that's there because you're you, and attention that's there because you're a customer. Between a relationship that gives you something and one that's counting something off you.

Everyone should have their own agent. They should just know who owns the terms.

A creator's biggest competitor doesn't need a better body or a better camera. It might be the assistant her customer told about that awful meeting this afternoon.

By evening, it doesn't need to introduce itself.
